Román pro muže

Under certain circumstances, it might have made a decent drama, but if someone wants to sell human arrogance and boundless rudeness as comedy, I have no mercy for them. This is despite the fact that Donutil understood exactly what to do and how to act in this role. I’m sick of what the current standard of "folk entertainment" is. I felt even more feelings of awkwardness than I did when watching From Subway with Love, but this time it was not because I was a man, but due to the screenwriter because if this is what his world looks like, I sincerely pity him. (21/09/2011)

Tomáš Bařina wanted to aim even higher than with Grapes. He exchanged the optimistic search for a sweet summer for an apparent bet on certainty. After all, Michal Viewegh is popular with all layers of readers and adaptations of his works, despite their level of quality, have always been successful. Except this one. The author's screenplay ambiguously plays both on the tone of absurdly humorous and also on the melancholic/thoughtful, which was always the priority for me. People who came to the cinema expecting vulgar fun, led by the bon vivant Miroslav Donutil, must have inevitably been stunned as early as the opening credits. And the viewers who, after trailers unnecessarily highlighting all the swear words you will hear in the film, wanted to indulge in new Czech nonsense, could make their argument both from those vulgarities and the lascivious plot. And it's a pity because it's obvious that Bařina and Viewegh wanted to turn the genre of vulgar frivolous Czech comedies upside down and create a clever absurdity, optimism with a sad smile, or maybe just a good film. They succeeded, but precisely because they try on multiple fronts, they could only succeed with a smaller percentage of the audience spectrum. (19/08/2011)

To be honest, I wasn't really looking forward to this movie. From the trailers it looked "not great". But in the end, I enjoyed it mainly because of its cast. Donutil's role was really top notch. I left the cinema with a smile and a lot of laughs...I will gladly watch Novel for Men again. FUNNY. (28/10/2010)

A bad film that gets one and a half stars rounded down. But it's not the director's fault, it's the screenwriter's. Uninteresting and unsympathetic characters talking nonsense, acting like either stupid idiots or stupid wannabe tough guys... And that's it. The star goes to Táňa Pauhofová (and it is mainly my lust for her), the rest to Tomáš Bařina and the music. Otherwise, it was quite disappointing. Wait a sec... Disappointment? Something I didn't expect anything from shouldn't disappoint me, right? And yet! (17/09/2010)

A pointless collection of overstretched shots, elevator music and cheap smirks for those who laugh when Donutil says “cock" and get a hardon at the idea that Táňa might show a tit. Viewegh's book version had at least some stimulating perspective on the reader-subject, whilst Bařina's film is just cheap. Vulgar and pathetic emaciation that can easily rival The Case of Unfaithful Klara, which at least it entertained with its soft-pornography, while Novel for Men is only good for a striptease among the ubiquitous shirts of television shows. (15/09/2010)