Black Jack is, in my opinion, Osamu Tezuka's best manga. This is the story of a two-fisted surgeon with the hands of a god, a man who explores the questions of life while delivering healing and justice through his razor-sharp scalpel and only slightly less acute intellect. Which is why I was thrilled to find out that Tezuka Productions had released a TV special featuring Black Jack, and even more thrilled to find out that they had included the single best storyline Tezuka ever wrote for the manga.
Let's get down to nuts and bolts.
ANIMATION
Tezuka's character designs might throw some people off (particularly Pinoco), but they have aged surprisingly well for this day and age. Animation is clean and well done. No complaints here.
SOUND
Voice acting is spot-on. Black Jack has exactly the kind of steady, competent voice that he needs, and Pinoco's voice actress does an admirable job for such a difficult part (Pinoco's accent is nearly indecipherable - she mixes J's with S's, W's with L's, and so on and so forth). Music is decent, nothing stands out, but nothing grating either.
STORY
First of all, a note on the opening sequence - kudos to the creators for a perfect summary of Black Jack's origin! I had chills running down my spine during the montage. They did a perfect job of explaining his appearance and the reason for his life's journey with a minimum of dialogue.
The bulk of the TV special features four short stories - "Where's a Doctor!", "The Disowned Son," "U-18 Knew It," and "Like a Pearl." No guns, mecha, or foxy women here, just a doctor dealing with the dilemmas of his profession and exploring the issues of life, death, morality, family, and the simple miracles of everyday living.
(By the way, "Like a Pearl" was my favorite story from the manga, and I was thrilled to see it in the TV special.)
CHARACTER
I have no complaints about Black Jack (his characterization is perfect) but Pinoco got short-changed. If you haven't read the manga, Pinoco was originally a vestigial siamese twin whom Jack pieced together into a cyborg-girl using artificial body parts. The anime doesn't explore this at all, which means that most first-time viewers will probably assume that Pinoco is just a child who lives with Jack for some reason. Pinoco is mainly used for comic relief, which ignores some of the more poignant aspects of her character. It also makes her insistence that she is Jack's wife a bit harder to understand.
VALUE
Excellent storyline, well-plotted, and eminently rewatchable. . . except for chapter 3, "U-18 knew it," which is the only thing that kept it from getting a higher score.
ENJOYMENT
Have I mentioned that I love Black Jack? Let me say it again: I loved the manga, and the TV special is a wonderful tribute to Tezuka's original creation. I much prefer it to the subsequent TV series (which is largely oriented towards children.) A special thanks to Tezuka Productions for updating Black Jack to modern standards of animation.