Hard to say
Just because 2 animals occupy the same niche and eat similar foods does not make them automatically taste the same. For example, the two most similar animals to what you've described are probably the Emu and the Cassowary, and what they taste like is as different as night and day.
Cassowary is an incredibly tough meat which requires days of slow cooking just to be palatable. There is a fun Australian saying about Cassowary meat that says that you should put a rock in the pot when you boil your Cassowary; you will know that the meat is ready when the rock is done.
In contrast, the Emu is also a large, strong, omnivorous flightless bird but it has a tender meat that is often compared to filet mignon. In fact, most people can not tell the difference between Emu and Beef. Like beef, emu is typically seared and served between rare and medium rare.
Domestication makes a big difference
When animals are domesticated for food, they almost always taste better than their wild counterparts. With a domestic animal, it tends to get less exercise and get breed for docility and greater body mass making its meat softer than its wild game counterparts. You also control what foods it is able to eat. For example, beef tastes very different based on what you feed the cow; so, we get different flavors of meat like corn beef, grass-fed, grain-fed, etc. In this way, even if your animal is typically a bit gamey those unpleasant tastes can be breed and fed away.
Cooking Method and Seasoning also matters a lot
Slow cooking any meat will destroy nearly all of its natural flavors; so, even if your meat is really tough and has a strong gamey flavor, boiling will eventually make it soft and flavorless. Slow cooked pork, beef, and chicken are all practically flavorless and get very similar final textures if simply boiled in water until done. The only noticeable difference between these meats is how we typically choose to season them when they are done cooking, but if you throw a chicken mix into pulled pork, it will taste just like pulled chicken.
It is only when meat is eaten rare and unseasoned that there is a big difference between one terrapod and another.
So, even if you do go with a not so pleasant natural flavor and texture, there are ways to make it taste more or less however you want.